Political Pondering: Adam Boulton Raises the Question - Do the Conservatives Harbor a Political Death Wish?

Divided Tories: A Perilous Path to Political Survival

In the ongoing saga of Tory rebellions, Prime Minister faces mounting challenges as the party grapples with internal divisions. Despite stern warnings about the perils of a divided front, the prime minister found himself at odds with 60 Conservative MPs who voted against the government's bill, raising questions about the party's coherence.

Isaac Levido, the architect of the Conservative general election campaign, emphasized the vulnerability of divided parties, stating unequivocally that "divided parties fail." However, his message seemed to fall on deaf ears as the rebellion persisted, featuring prominent figures like former home secretary Suella Braverman and deputy Robert Jenrick.

The rebellion momentarily dwindled during the "third reading," with over 40 MPs opting to step back from potentially toppling the bill and jeopardizing both the government and themselves. Despite the prime minister's attempt to declare party unity, murmurs of discontent persisted, with reports of Tory MPs submitting votes of no confidence in Chancellor Rishi Sunak.

The looming question now hovers over the Conservative Party's future: Do they have a collective death wish as a party of government? The noticeable divisions within the party are not lost on the public, with recent figures indicating a staggering 70% division among Conservatives in December, contrasting sharply with a mere 8% unity.

As the party grapples with its internal challenges, the broader concern emerges – do the Conservatives genuinely aspire to win the next election? The precarious balance between party unity and internal dissent raises doubts about their ability to secure public trust and navigate the path to political victory.

Conservative Crisis: Navigating Disillusionment as Polls and Party Unity Spiral

As the Conservative Party faces a multifaceted crisis, recent surveys by YouGov paint a grim picture of dwindling public support and internal dissent. The specter of disillusionment loomed large in January 2022 during the "partygate" revelations, and its jaws have remained wide open ever since, fueled by a consistent lead for Labour in opinion polls over the past two years.

YouGov's recent polls indicate that the chasm between the parties may be widening further, with a survey commissioned by the newly formed Conservative Britain Alliance projecting a potential loss of 196 seats for the Tories, reducing their parliamentary presence to a mere 169 MPs compared to Labour's 385. A separate monthly poll for The Times echoes this sentiment, revealing an increased 27-point lead for Labour in voting intention.

In the face of this dire situation, Prime Minister's attempts to project unity within the party come at a cost. He has refrained from taking disciplinary action against rebels who voted against the government on the Rwanda bill, opting instead to align with the right-wing faction. Rishi Sunak's decision to instruct civil servants to ignore last-minute orders from the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) further underscores the party's shift toward nativist rhetoric, labeling the ECHR as a "foreign court.

This stance, however, raises questions about the party's commitment to international institutions, given the UK's founding membership in the ECHR since 1959. The complexity of the situation is heightened by the fact that some rebels are seasoned veterans of post-referendum Brexit deliberations, while others, like Lee Anderson, were elected in 2019 under Boris Johnson's leadership.

As the Conservative Party grapples with internal dissent, a widening gap in the polls, and a strategic shift in rhetoric, the road to political recovery seems elusive. The coming months will be critical in determining whether the Conservatives can navigate this crisis and regain the trust of the electorate, or if the current state of disillusionment will persist, further shaping the political landscape.

Crossroads of Contention: Rebels, Public Opinion, and the Rifts within the Conservative Agenda

In the unfolding political drama, a momentary weakness has surfaced within the Conservative ranks, as rebels show no inclination towards compromise. Instead, they advocate for a complete withdrawal from the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR), a move that aligns the UK with nations like Russia and Belarus in Europe.

Despite the prime minister's assertion that his Rwanda plan represents the "will of the people," skepticism abounds. The absence of this proposal in the Conservative Party's 2019 manifesto, coupled with a public opinion split, raises questions about its effectiveness. A majority, 53%, deems it ineffective, with 40% advocating for its abandonment compared to 37% urging its continuation.

The focus on the Rwanda scheme, while generating controversy, serves as a diversion from broader immigration challenges. Cross-Channel migrants, while dramatic, only represent a fraction of the over 600,000 net total individuals annually entering the UK. The proposed number for potential relocation to Rwanda, if the scheme materializes, is even smaller.

Chancellor Rishi Sunak's "Stop the Boats" policy, aimed at addressing migration, appears to divert attention from the complex issues surrounding mass migration. Sunak strategically targets Labour's stance, accusing them of planning to scrap the Rwanda scheme even if it proves effective. This narrative aims to portray Labour as lacking a coherent plan, though its impact on Keir Starmer and the party remains uncertain.

Interestingly, Sunak's emphasis on the Rwanda scheme aligns with the preferences of 46% of Conservative voters from 2019, who believe in its efficacy, while an even larger majority, 63%, supports the government's continuation of the policy. This suggests that Sunak may prioritize maintaining support within his electoral base over strictly adhering to the perceived "will of the people.

As the political landscape navigates these contentious issues, immigration emerges as a significant concern for some voters. However, the broader consensus indicates that the economy and the cost of living are paramount concerns across all categories and classes. The intersection of rebels, public sentiment, and divergent party priorities creates a complex tapestry that will shape the political trajectory in the coming months.

Conservative Quandary: Internal Strife, Electoral Retreat, and the Shadow of Leadership Transition

Within the Conservative Party, internal divisions are escalating, creating a tumultuous landscape where MPs grapple with the looming challenges of tax cuts and the upcoming Budget on March 6. The party's ability to resist or succumb to internal pressures will be put to the test, with many MPs advocating for tax cuts beyond what they perceive as financially feasible for the country.

A prevailing sentiment among Tory MPs suggests that the once-defined path to election victory is now diminishing, leading some to shift their priorities away from winning and towards the future of the party and their individual political careers. Notably, over 54 MPs have decided to retire, signaling a sense of resignation about the party's prospects.

Amidst the tumult, the looming threat from the Reform party has prompted some within the Conservative ranks to advocate for aligning party policy more closely with Nigel Farage's agenda. While Farage garners popularity among the party's aging membership, he remains ineligible to stand for leadership. As the specter of defeat hovers, figures like Braverman, Jenrick, and Badenoch position themselves for potential leadership vacancies they anticipate post-defeat.

On the opposing front, One Nation conservatives, who weathered the purges of the Johnson era, remain loyal but increasingly find themselves out of sync with the party's trajectory. Resigned to the idea that victory in the next election is unlikely, they navigate the turbulent waters with a sense of realism.

Some within the party foresee a need to elect a more extremist leader, followed by another defeat, to reclaim the party's identity—a sentiment reminiscent of Labour's Neil Kinnock's call to "get their party back." Interestingly, the evolving landscape suggests that the new roster of Conservative MPs may lean more moderate, given the prevalence of centrist candidates and the anticipated defeat of several "red wall" Tories.

Chancellor Rishi Sunak, eyeing a tenure extension until at least autumn, faces additional challenges with parliamentary by-elections in Wellingborough, Kingswood, and likely Blackpool North on the horizon. The coming months promise to be a critical juncture for the Conservative Party, as it grapples with internal strife, electoral setbacks, and the potential for leadership transition.

Conservative Conundrum: Navigating Electoral Challenges and the Shadow of Political Uncertainty

As the Conservative Party faces a series of formidable electoral tests, the task of maintaining recent electoral momentum proves increasingly challenging. The impending local elections in London and other key areas present a crucial litmus test that could either unite or further divide the party.

In the face of these challenges, Chancellor Rishi Sunak finds himself at the helm, steering the party through uncertain waters. The recent dismissive reaction to Issac Levido's warning underscores the internal dynamics at play, raising questions about the party's ability to weather the storm and emerge unscathed.

The upcoming elections pose a dual challenge for the Conservatives – holding on to recent electoral gains while navigating potential fractures within the party. The unpredictable nature of these tests introduces an element of political uncertainty, leaving room for unforeseen developments that could reshape the political landscape.

On the opposing front, Labour faces an uphill battle, requiring a significant swing in its favor to secure a majority government. Despite current opinion polls favoring the party, the stark reality of election day looms, and expectations are tempered within Keir Starmer's team.

As the political narrative unfolds, the warning from Issac Levido takes on a prophetic tone, with the Conservatives' response becoming a defining chapter in the chronicle of a potentially foretold political demise. The intricate dance between electoral challenges, internal dynamics, and unforeseen events will determine the party's fate in the coming months, adding layers of complexity to an already intricate political landscape.

In conclusion, the Conservative Party stands at a critical juncture, facing a formidable array of electoral challenges and internal divisions. As the impending local elections and other crucial tests loom, the ability to maintain recent electoral gains while navigating potential fractures within the party remains uncertain.

The dismissive reaction to Issac Levido's warning underscores the complexities and uncertainties that lie ahead. The upcoming elections will not only serve as a barometer of the party's current standing but also as a potential catalyst for internal strife or unity.

Labour, on the other hand, confronts its own set of challenges, requiring a substantial swing in its favor to secure a majority government. The interplay between current opinion polls and the realities of election day introduces an element of unpredictability.

As the political narrative unfolds, the warning from Issac Levido takes on a significant role in shaping the chronicle of the Conservative Party's future. The intricate dance between electoral challenges, internal dynamics, and unforeseen events will determine the party's fate in the coming months.

In this complex and ever-evolving political landscape, the Conservatives are confronted with the task of not only holding onto electoral momentum but also managing internal divisions to emerge stronger. The unfolding chapters of this political saga will reveal whether the dismissive reaction to warnings proves prescient or if unforeseen developments alter the course of the party's destiny.